A year ago, I shared an experiment on LinkedIn: “If AI can create a shockingly accurate headshot for you, are you conflicted about using it? Does it make you less human?” I paired it with my own AI-generated headshot. The post took off: 17,000+ impressions, 100+ comments, and a wide range of reactions.
Some said, “Looks great — mine’s AI too!” Others were more skeptical: “It’s good, but it feels … empty. Like something’s missing in the eyes.”
And then Marty Neumeier dropped a truth bomb:
“Maybe the real value of an image lies elsewhere. When tools are so easy to use, truth becomes harder to find.” That statement stuck with me. While my new AI-generated headshot accomplished my goal that day (a quick and cost-effective avatar), it wasn’t authentic.
People, like brands, thrive on authenticity. Especially today.
We live in a world where anything can be manufactured: attention, aesthetics, even emotion. AI gives us infinite content. Flawless renderings. But in that flood of sameness, authenticity has become an increasingly valuable asset.
So, when I got the news about being featured on the cover of Branders Magazine last month, I knew it was time to ditch that cheap solution and invest in something more authentic (shoutout to Carrie Nelson and Steven Picanza). Reminded of the power of an imperfectly genuine photograph, I was hungry to capture the real me. There’s a story in every real wrinkle and subtle expression. There’s energy and spontaneity that AI just can’t capture.
Here’s the broader takeaway: Your brand — personal or corporate — isn’t just a logo, a tagline, or a perfect-looking headshot. It’s the story people believe about you. And in an era when polished pixels are cheap, what people are really craving is proof of soul. A reason to believe that what you stand for is rooted in something real.
AI is a tool. Trust is the strategy.
Authenticity isn’t just a brand value — it’s the brand advantage.